Just In
for The Pianist

2/1/2009 c1 1DrenchedinWine
I like your descriptions of sounds with color. Also, I'm a fan of the juxtaposition between the extraordinary supernatural mood created by the music, and the mundane physical world and its society. I also like that your characters have no names and are vivid but anonymous.
1/27/2009 c1 5Romantic Nun
This was really cute. I liked all the imagery you used, it really gave a bold picture in my head. I liked the last line as well. Short, sweet, and very well done. good job! :)
1/26/2009 c1 4B. J. Winters
A nice read. I was looking for something with a bit of a bedtime story feel and this was a pleasant late night surprise. I liked that you used a broad range of senses and painted a clear picture that was easy to relate to.

I liked the last line. Made me smile.
1/22/2009 c1 criti-sized
At first a person could think that she's merely crazily infatuated with the pianist, but come to find out she's not, lol. This was very nice. The shortness of it intensified the way it was supposed to come off and gave it a great touch.

1/20/2009 c1 raineyday
This is beautiful, absolutely beautiful. I'm a pianist myself, and I really appreciate anything that relates to the instrument, and you captured the sensuality of the music so well. This is such a rich piece for being as short as it is; you achieve so much in so few words. And the first sentence! It's only two words long, but it works SO well. Wonderful job!
1/20/2009 c1 8Irresistible Apple
This is gorgeous. I love the description you used, especially in the second line with, "brash scarlet, refreshing green, electric blue, exploding in a rainbow of sound." to describe the sound of the piano. I loved how you compared the music to color, very original. Anyway, very nice job with this!
1/20/2009 c1 Chancee
Short cute and definitely one that you will continue. I like it very much. I don't really see any problems and hopefully we get his name, her name, whether or not he does this as his full time job, Is he a great pianist?, budding beginner, or just someone who plays well enough to be on stage.

Is she ordinary but extraordinary in his sights, and is he the silent but passionate type when they get home?

Hopefully these questions will inspire you to continue and one last thing What is she wearing that really gives meaning behind his smile?

Thanks for writing this!
1/20/2009 c1 The Tragedian
it's nice. Most people can't do this type of text well, but you did it well.


he Review Game
23 « Prev Page 1 2

Twitter . Help . Sign Up . Cookies . Privacy . Terms of Service